Evaluating the GW Colonials for the '64 season, Street And Smith's
College Football Yearbook noted that "The appearance of four promising Negro
sophomore prospects, first of their race to seek positions on the varsity,
was timed with the appearance of enough talent that (head coach) Jim Camp
sought to groom three units in Spring practice." One of these players was
Garry Lyle, a running back out of Verona, PA who had starred on that
freshman team in '63. He was even better as a soph, moving to the QB
position before the season was over, and finishing at 5-4. Lyle was
definitely the guy to stop and as the first African-American to be named to
the All Southern Conference team he was a marked man. With the change in
substitution rules the year before, many schools were switching to platoon
football but at both Cincinnati and GW, there were plenty of players still
going both ways and Lyle was also a very effective secondary man as well as
a kick and punt returner. Two-way guard Doug McNeil was their stud lineman
with Lou Astolfi a player we needed to control. Another outstanding player
was halfback Mike Holloran.
In 1965, GW again was looking to challenge for the conference title but
Lyle was injured in the season's opener and could do little more than place
kick. I had the pleasure of speaking with GW's former two-time All Southern
Conference and Honorable Mention All American defensive back and wingback
Tom Metz, originally out of the Philadelphia area and now living comfortably
in Colorado. He and George Washington's archivist Mr. Lyle Slovick provided
a great deal of information, and our conversations continued to return to
the 1964 game. The biggest victory of 1964 was against a thirty-five
point favorite Cincinnati team, the Missouri Valley Conference co-champion.
The 1964 and '65 Bearcat contingents were loaded with great athletes, most
notably QB Brig Owens and HB Al Nelson, two future pro stars. Against Tulsa
in the '64 contest, a 28-23 UC win that determined the conference title,
both offenses rolled up and down the field in an offensive shoot-out that
matched Tulsa's pass-catch duo of Jerry Rhome and end Howard Twilley with
UC's Owens and Nelson. Metz noted the superiority of UC's athletes, and that
they had a lot more team size and speed. "We were outweighed twenty pounds
per man and Cincinnati had great athletes" but in the films of the Tulsa vs.
UC game, played the week prior to the GW tilt, and the film that Head Coach
Camp had the squad focus upon, GW made a startling discovery. All-MVC RB
Nelson, if running to his right, would place his right hand on the ground.
If Nelson ran to his left, his left hand would go to the ground. Metz said
that as obvious as this was, once pointed out by his coaching staff, it was
never altered by Nelson nor the Bearcat staff. This allowed the focus to
fall upon Nelson and the defensive signal would be yelled as "Cincy left" or
"Cincy right" dependent upon Nelson's hand placement. The front wall of the
Colonials would then slant to the side of the tipped-off run, stifling the
UC rushing attack and pulling off one of the greatest upsets of the season
and one of the biggest in GW history. Metz stated that "You were big
favorites, but we realized that Nelson's movement was predictably consistent
and we helped ourselves with a bit of 'trickery.'" Metz explained that
"Without a huddle, after the first kickoff, GW lined up with a very
unbalanced line. Both guards and tackles lined up on one side, so the only
lineman left of the center to the narrow side of the field was the tight
end. Everyone else was on the wide side of the field. Garry received the
ball from the center and simply ran to the wide side of the field, with the
entire team blocking for him. When the tackle was finally made, GW lined up
with the unbalanced line the other way, to the wide side, again without a
huddle. Garry ran again. On the third play, he scored. It was unbelievable."
Despite the effectiveness of the unorthodox alignment, Cincinnati with all
of its talent was winning with two minutes remaining in the game by a score
of 15-14. The Colonials forced and recovered a fumble and Mark Gross came on
to kick a field goal for a 17-15 GW victory. Metz summarized the great
performance, dogged play, and "most memorable upset" by stating that "It was
an unbelievable tribute to Jim Camp's coaching talent." Metz also pointed
out that one of GW's key players and one of his close friends, LB Tom
Reilly, had to go against one of his relatives, UC's dominant tackle Bob
Taylor and afterward, let Taylor know the specifics of how the upset was
constructed.
Unfortunately, Lyle's early-season injury in '65 reduced the team's
effectiveness and the 5-5 finish was considered to be quite admirable in
Camp's estimation due to an inordinate number of injuries. UC traveled to DC
to play the 1965 contest and somewhat avenged the '64 upset loss with a 13-3
win and a rushing output of 236 yards. Metz was a two-way star who stood out
as a DB and also caught thirty-two passes for 340 yards, but Lyle was
relegated to doing little more than place kicking and left school prior to
the '66 season. He was drafted in the third round by the Bears and enjoyed a
productive seven-year pro career as a DB and kick return man. Garry's son
Keith was a star at the University Of Virginia and played DB in the NFL,
primarily for the Rams. Although some saw the 1957 Sun Bowl team's
performance as the program's high-water mark, GW competed well in the
Southern Conference and Camp was coach of the year a number of times. A
decision was made to drop football when a new president came in. Despite
playing at the NFL Redskin's stadium, small crowds and dwindling finances
brought about the decision and a major initiative was started to enhance the
campus infrastructure and academic programs. Both goals were successful as
George Washington achieved a deserved reputation as one of the nation's
premiere universities with a beautiful campus. The "Buff And Blue" Colonials
of GW always looked great with their white helmets, gold center stripe, and
two flanking stripes in navy blue. On their white visiting team jerseys, the
helmet striping was matched by the same shoulder insert and sleeve numerals
which gave a great look to the entire uniform. The navy blue home jersey
with white front, back, and shoulder numbers and white knit sleeve trim
matched well with the nice looking helmet that had the players'
identifying numerals placed at the back of the headgear. As one of the last
of the major universities playing in a large urban setting, the demise of
GW's football program was, in retrospect, a view of the sport's future as
many of the mid-level entries were forced to either de-emphasize or
eliminate their programs or make a major commitment to playing "big time"
football. While many mourned the loss of football, GW made its passing work
for them as it became a leading academic institution.